Free overnight shipping — fully insured on every order.
My Watch GuruBuy, sell & trade desk

Journal

Values, guides and when to sell

What your watch is worth, what moves that number, and how to get the best figure on the day you decide to let it go.

Latest articles

The Datejust Nobody Bid OnHow a filler-case Rolex quietly turned into a value hold, and what still moves the resale number. Submariner Resale, Answered StraightThe value questions buyers actually ask about the steel Sub, and the honest numbers behind each. Two Presidents, One Week, One LessonWhat a pair of identical Day-Dates showed about where the resale spread on a President really lives. 3.05 Millimeters of Royal OakThe one measurement that sets the Jumbo apart, and whether it earns its resale premium over the 15500. Ballon Bleu: 42mm or 36mm?Two sizes of the same Cartier, two very different resale outcomes. Which one keeps your money. Wire or Card: Reading the Payment TellHow a seller wants to be paid says more about the risk than the photos do, and what protects your money. Six Grand, One Oyster PerpetualA buyer, a budget, and the resale trade-off hiding inside the dial color you pick. Where the GMT-Master II Sits NowThe Pepsi came off its peak and stopped falling. A buy, wait, or sell read for this month. Reading a Sky-Dweller ReferenceThe digits that set the price, the generation split that sets the value, and the one to chase. The Steel Daytona and Why Its Value Won't Sit StillWhat a steel Daytona fixes in an outfit, and why that same range keeps its resale number firm. Reading a GMT-Master by Its BezelThe bezel tells you the reference, the era, and most of the price, so start there before you pay. Yacht-Master Questions Buyers Ask Before PayingStraight answers on Yacht-Master references, resale, and the retail-day haircut buyers dread. An Offshore Crossed the Desk With Its Whole KitA complete-kit Offshore that sold itself, and what completeness is worth at resale. 36mm: The Explorer Spec That Sets the PriceCase diameter decides the Explorer's buyer pool, and the buyer pool decides the price. Aquanaut 5167A vs 5168G: Which One to HoldSteel 5167A or white-gold 5168G: which Aquanaut trades faster, and which is the more interesting hold. Spotting a Sea-Dweller That Isn't RightThe tells that separate a right Sea-Dweller from a wrong one, and the clasp check most buyers skip. $9,000, One Buyer, and the Discontinued MilgaussA $9,000 budget, a discontinued Milgauss, and whether scarcity beats liquidity on resale. The Explorer II Slid Back to Retail: Here's the ReadThe Explorer II slid back toward retail; here is the buy, wait, or sell read for this month. Yacht-Master II: Reading the Reference Before You Read the PriceA five-digit code that prices a listing in seconds, and the traps that quietly cut the number. The Air-King Is Quiet Money, and It Wants to Stay That WayHow to wear the no-date Oystersteel Rolex, and why you buy it to wear rather than to flip. 1976: The Steel Watch That Cost as Much as GoldFrom the 3700 Jumbo to the froth of 2022 and the calmer numbers that followed. Pearlmaster: Where the Money Actually SitsA discontinued gem-set Rolex that resells closer to melt-plus-stones than to its original sticker. The 5396 That Sold Itself in a WeekOn the Complications line, papers and a sharp case set the price as much as the reference. 41 Millimeters: The Spec That Made the 5270 Read RightThe perpetual calendar chronograph, its debated early dial, and which one holds value best. Code 11.59: Time-Only or Chronograph on the Resale MathTwo references, one case, and the honest tie-breaker for a family that moves slowly used. The Calatrava Tell Most Buyers SkipRedials, polished lugs, and the extract cross-reference that separates a fair price from a costly one. Five Grand, a Big Wrist, and a Fear of DepreciationWhy the used Luminor is a buyer's watch, and the reference that protects your exit. The Steel Santos and the Flat Line That Tells You EverythingWhy the QuickSwitch steel large model trades near retail, and what that stability means for a buyer or a seller this month. Reading a Cartier Tank: Four Fields That Set the PriceFamily, size, movement, metal. Decode those and you have priced a Tank before you see the photo. Styling the Big Bang Without Hurting Its ResaleThe wrist the case was built for, the pairings that work, and the material choice that decides what it sells for later. The Word on the Dial: Tudor's Oysterdate, Then and NowHow a name printed on a 1970s chronograph became a value story about originality, condition, and the honest example. Submariner Value, Answered StraightThe questions buyers ask first, and the one they are afraid to ask, about what a Submariner is really worth. Two Monacos, One Honest DialA restored dial cost a seller three buyers. On a Monaco, condition is not on top of the reference, it is the reference. A Third in Gold: What Two-Tone Sports Watches Really CostThe gold premium you pay up front, the discount the used market applies later, and the one configuration worth buying. Gold, Steel, or Two-Tone: Matching the Metal to Your LifeBuying a milestone watch as a gift? The right metal has less to do with taste and more to do with how the wearer actually spends their days. What Our Bench Really Checks Before a Watch SellsA plain look at what our watchmakers do before a pre-owned watch earns its listing — and why that trail matters when you resell. Choosing an Era, Not Just a Reference NumberThe same signature detail reads differently across decades, and the era you pick shapes what you actually live with on the wrist. Gold, Steel, or Two-Tone: Pick the Metal You Live InThe case metal you choose says more about your week than your wallet — here's how to read the history and match it to real life. What Box and Papers Really Do to Resale ValueA full set can move the number more than collectors admit — but the reasons are historical, not magical, and they don't apply evenly. Choose the Era Before You Choose the ReferenceA reference number tells you what a watch is; the era tells you who it was built for and what it will ask of you. Gold, Steel, or Two-Tone: Matching Metal to Your DaysThe metal you choose says less about your budget than about the life your wrist actually lives. What Our Watchmakers Look For Before A Watch Is ListedAuthentication isn't a scan of a serial number; it's reading a watch against the era it claims to come from. What Box and Papers Actually Do to Resale ValueThe full set commands a premium for a real reason, but the size of that premium depends on the reference, the era, and the buyer across the table.

Model valuation guides

A specialist reads it firstA watch specialist goes over every piece — ours or yours — before any number is put on it.
A figure inside 24 hoursSend the reference and a few photos; you get a firm offer the next business day, no obligation either way.
Insured in both directionsFully insured, signature-required shipping to us and straight back to you if you decide to pass.
Cash or trade creditTake the offer as cash, or roll it into whatever you buy next — start a valuation.